According to althusser state is a repressive apparatus. Those attitudes superstructure then influence the capitalist classs decisions related to labor issues base. The capitalist class is the base and the working class is the superstructure. Comments on terry eagletons base and superstructure revisited. In the preface the superstructure is characterised by marx as legal and political, and this suggests that the state looms large in its composition, although it does not follow that the entire state system is included in the superstructure. He accepted that those in control of the base could affect the superstructure, but he wanted to introduce a plausible way in which this happened. The marxist theory of history explains the fundamental relationship between material conditions and ideas through the concept of base and superstructure. Three reading strategies published by oxyscholar, 2014. The totality is overdetermineda concept borrowed from freudmeaning that the totality is a complex whole without clearly discernible causal relations. Ideology and ideological state apparatuses by louis althusser 1969. Jun 24, 2016 althussers version of marxism rejects both economic determinism and humanism. Gramsci, maintains that science is a phenomenon which cannot be ranked under the category of superstructure.
Louis al thusser was born in algeria in 1918 and died in france in 1990. Base and superstructure in marxist cultural theory a ny modern approach to a marxist theory of culture must begin by considering the proposition of a determining base and a determined superstructure. It gives an example of an application of the theory to 1968. The base is a combination of the forces of productionraw materials, industrial processes. Marxs base superstructure metaphor should be read as referring to foundations, e. What are the social infrastructure and superstructure, as defined by marx and althusser. Pdf the basesuperstructure hypothesis and the foundations of. Start studying week 3 marxist theory of base and superstructure. Gramsci and althusser notes michigan state university. Click here to download this weeks paper in pdf format. Althusser presents an interesting reading of marx, but his interpretation is incompatible with marx. Base and superstructure in marxist cultural theory 3 raymond williams any modern approach to a marxist theory of culture must begin by considering the proposition of a determining base and a determined superstructure. How does the marxist superstructure legitimize its base. Karl marx ideology basesuperstructure class commodity fetishism louise althusser ideological state apparatus interpellation guy debord spectacle isolation false choice change slavoj zizek unconcious fantasy superstructure and base bolded is base relations of.
Even though the base is foundational, both the base and superstructure are important. Across these disciplines the base superstructure relationship, and the contents of each, may take different forms. Revisiting the roots of neomarxism in critical educational theory wayne au. Louis althusser s renowned short text ideology and ideological state apparatuses radically transformed the concept of the subject, the understanding of the state and even the very frameworks of cultural, political and literary theory. Althusser extends this topographical paradigm by stating that the infrastructural economic base is endowed with an index of effectivity which enables it to ultimately determine the functioning of the superstructure. Althusser enjoys the reputation of having proposed a new, struc.
Louis althusser, on the reproduction of capitalism. Base and superstructure in marxist cultural theory is a critical essay critic and an influential figure in the new left, raymond henry williams. The contention is whether the relationship between base and superstructure is simple and deterministic or one that is complex and dialectic. Louis althusser builds on the work of jacques lacan to understand the way ideology functions in society. Freudomarxist wilhelm reichs discipline of analysis known as sex economy is an attempt to understand the divergence of the perceived base and superstructure that occurred during the global economic crisis from 1929 to 1933. Comments on terry eagletons base and superstructure revisited john dupre l et me. The base comprises the forces and relations of production e. Instead of being structured into two levels, althusser argues that society has three levels, or structures. Feb 16, 2005 this ignores marxs assertion in the preface that the economic base conditions the superstructure marx, 1996.
In other words, as the components of the economic base change, so does its influence on political, social, and cultural institutions, such as the family and the state, which comprise the superstructure. So far this article has been about the relationship of base and superstructure in general. For althusser, the basesuperstructure is a distinction containing rather. In marxist theory, capitalist society consists of two parts. Althusser s version of marxism rejects both economic determinism and humanism. Jan 24, 2020 base and superstructure are two linked theoretical concepts developed by karl marx, one of sociologys founders. Williams althusser speaks of the relative autonomy and reciprocal action of the superstructure. Marxist media theory daniel chandler opposition to functionalism opposition to liberal pluralism base and superstructure media as means of production ideology media as amplifiers the constitution of the subject differences within marxism the frankfurt school althusser gramsci and hegemony stuart hall limitations of marxist analysis. Base and superstructure understanding visual culture. Marxist media theory daniel chandler opposition to functionalism opposition to liberal pluralism base and superstructure media as means of production ideology media as amplifiers the constitution of the subject differences within marxism the frankfurt school althusser gramsci and hegemony stuart hall. Ideology and ideological state apparatuses summary by althusser. Pdf more than a quarter of a century after louis althussers heyday, one.
Althusser wants to argue that in fact the base and the superstructure are interdependent elements of the totality, that neither shoulder the full burden of social determination. Gramscis concept of hegemony and its relation to marxist. Louis althusser complicates marxs understanding of the relation between base and superstructure by adding his concept of ideological state apparatuses. To describe him thus is immediately to invite controversy. First is the peculiar effect of relations of production on the forces of production. Sep 25, 2016 louis althussers renowned short text ideology and ideological state apparatuses radically transformed the concept of the subject, the understanding of the state and even the very frameworks of cultural, political and literary theory. Define superstructure and base again, and ask how it manifests in. He taught philosophy for many years at the ecole n ormale. In fact, what is hidden beneath this term is a set of theses and arguments that compose an attempt 1 janik. Engels explains that the base determines the superstructure only in the last instance. Second, for althusser, there is no clear dividing line between base and superstructure. Get an answer for what is a summary of ideology and ideological state apparatuses. We have to understand the imagery of base and superstructure, elaborating its theoretical and not simply descriptive. Louis althusser, the ideological state apparatus, and.
Determination in the last instance by economic base, yet. The base does not simply determine which factor in society is dominant, it also exerts an active influence on the superstructure. Doc base and superstructure in marxism lisbern shawn. Base and superstructure an overview sciencedirect topics.
In economism, the economic base of society is seen as determining everything else in the superstructure, including social, political and intellectual consciousness. The economic level all of those activities which involve producing something or meeting a need. Althusser argues that the function of ideology is to reproduce this submission and this ability, but to comprehend this process requires a good deal more than the traditional metaphor of base superstructure. The italian marxist antonio gramsci developed the key concept of cultural hegemony during his imprisonment by the italian state under mussolinis fascist rule. Base and superstructure in marxist cultural theory. In althussers conception, the social structure, represented as a complex whole structured in dominance is characterised by a series of. Jun 01, 2018 class relations within the base influence certain gendered and racialized attitudes and systems. It provides a good snapshot of the relationship between the means of production, the relations of production, and the ideas, consciousness, an. The text has influenced thinkers such as judith butler, ernesto laclau and slavoj zizek. Marx believed that the economic base of society is seen as determining everything else in society which he calls the superstructure, which includes social, cultural, political and intellectual systems. When push comes to shove, the base is going to exert its force on the.
In the preface to a contribution to the critique of political economy 1859, karl marx wrote that the economic structure of society forms the real basis on which rises a legal and political superstructure. Dec 14, 2017 gramsci based his ideas of hegemony on the marxist theoretical concepts of base and superstructure. Economism also called vulgar marxism is a key feature of classical marxism orthodox or fundamentalist marxism. According to this view ideological practices such as the mass media are relatively autonomous from economic determination see stevenson 1995. Thistheoryshowsthatclassconflictsandworkerstrugglesaresodeeplyingrained insocietiesthattheyare reflectedinliterature,goingbacktothestancethatthe. Base and superstructure in marxs theory of history. This ignores marxs assertion in the preface that the economic base conditions the superstructure marx, 1996. Althusser looked at the base superstructure dichotomy and saw something wanting. To make sense of this phenomenon, reich recategorized social ideology as an element in the basenot the superstructure.
In althusser s conception, the social structure, represented as a complex whole structured in dominance is characterised by a series of. But althusser was the key figure in modern theorizing on this question who clearly broke with some of the old protocols and provided a persuasive alternative which remains. What are the differences between superstructure and. Economic determinism and relative autonomy of superstructure. Can someone help me better understand determinationinthe. Karl marx ideology base superstructure class commodity fetishism louise althusser ideological state apparatus interpellation guy debord spectacle isolation false choice change slavoj zizek unconcious fantasy superstructure and base bolded is base relations of. Base refers to the production forces, or the materials and resources, that generate the goods society needs. Marxs theory of base and superstructure can be found in the disciplines of political science, sociology, anthropology, and psychology as utilized by marxist. Rather than the base being a definitive entity and the superstructure being a mere reflection of it, althusser portrays the base as having less significance and the superstructure as being largely selfdetermining.
Pdf purposeto defend the thesis that the basesuperstructure. But the proposition of base and superstructure, with its figurative element, with its suggestion of a definite and fixed spatial relationship, constitutes, at least in certain hands, a very specialized and at times unacceptable version of the other proposition. But there are certain peculiarities about their relation under capitalism that deserve a brief mention. Superstructure describes all other aspects of society. The most important passage on this can be found in marxs preface to a contribution to the critique of political economy. He taught philosophy for many years at the ecole n ormale superieure in paris and was a leading intellectual in the french communist. Louis al thusser was born in algeria in 1918 and died in. Introduces the notion of ideology and the primacy of economic production within marxist thought. Marx distinguished among various levels in a society. Define superstructure and base again, and ask how it manifests in dakar.
Marxs theory of base and superstructure can be found in the disciplines of political science, sociology, anthropology, and psychology as utilized by marxist scholars. Raymond williams, base and superstructure in marxist. Superstructure is autonomous, base is determined in the last instance. In a certain sense, this is anticipated by althusser and his account of. Get an answer for what are the differences between superstructure and infrastructure in marxism. He thus moves away from the earlier marxist understanding of ideology. According to the theory of history, the character of the legal and political superstructure is explained by the nature of the economic structure.
Stuart halls death removes from the scene one of the most influential marxists in britain of the past 50 years. The problem with the base superstructure construct is that it is static. In the earlier model, ideology was believed to create what was termed false consciousness, a false understanding of the way the world functioned for example, the suppression of the fact that the products we purchase on. From a strictly theoretical point of view this is not, in fact, where we might choose to. How is the reproduction of the relations of production secured. Base and superstructure are two linked theoretical concepts developed by karl marx, one of sociologys founders. Stuart hall in perspective international socialism. A brief explanation of the concepts of base and superstructure in marxs conception of society. Jun 25, 2015 among one of these thinkers was the french structuralist louis althusser. For althusser, there is no unmediated access to truth. From a strictly theoretical point of view this is not, in fact, where we might choose to begin. The piece is, in fact, an extract from a much longer book, on the. After reading this article you will learn about the base and superstructure.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Capitalist class at the base controls the superstructure through two tools. What is a summary of ideology and ideological state. Functions by ideology it is secured by the legalpolitical and ideological superstructure it is.
369 636 1013 1676 724 693 234 744 131 1297 662 211 739 1625 568 712 924 1088 1211 1142 1583 145 1415 373 1347 916 1671 572 1159 1518 781 786 265 121 813 704 757 1329 871 616 838 179